Showing posts with label Gartner. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gartner. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 16, 2011

Agile is the way to sucess

Completely agree with the author on this one:
According to Gartner, 70 to 80 percent of business intelligence projects fail. The solution could be a more agile development process — and organization.
Having been through this, BI is seen as vaporware until something is delivered.  Users can "test" a new application, they can see mock ups, they are involved from the very beginning.  Enterprise application also have something called a release schedule, which BI generally does not have.  An application evolves, a BI report is the end point generally. 

The issue with an agile development life-cycle that I have run into is that the people that are on the project have to be able to adapt to requirements that are not clear cut, the end result is not known, and they generally have to be free thinking and have a keen awareness of what the business is what they MAY be looking for.  In a best case scenario the end user is involved not only at the requirements phase, but going forward so as to clarify, add, remove requirements as the process moves along.  Given how the economy is, this may be harder than it was in the past, where users are more concerned about getting their day to day done as opposed to helping with enhancements.

Last point, what is a BI project failure?  Is it the system never gets put into production, or the system does not live up to expectations?  If it is the latter, I can believe the percentages, since it never seems that people use the system as they said they would when they were giving the requirements.  To illustrate, we put in a module for one specific group of users that took six months to develop and deliver (not very agile), and the end result, 10 reports a week being run.  I would classify that a failure in that the ROI will never be there at that rate.  There is also an opportunity cost associated with that as well, those 6 months could have been used on something else that may have been more useful to the business. 

Ease of Use versus Power


Very interesting read (here is the link)
“With ‘ease of use’ now surpassing ‘functionality’ for the first time as the dominant BI platform buying criterion, vocal, demanding and influential business users are increasingly driving BI purchasing decisions, most often choosing easier to use data discovery tools over traditional BI platforms — with or without IT's consent,” said Mr. Bertram.
I like how they are starting to realize that ease of use is better to have than a whole lot of bells and whistles that no one uses. What does scare me is the with or without the IT consent.  I have been, and will continue to go through this, given that all this can do is lead to the infamous 'spreadmarts', which can lead to more than one version of the truth.  Its a catch 22, make it simple enough for anyone to install and you get a propagation of data all over the enterprise, or make it so IT has to support it and you get a stable, but much less agile solution.  It is a tough choice.